Go Back
Slice of Amish peanut butter cream pie on a white plate in front of the whole pie in a clear glass pie dish

Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

A baked pie crust layered with a sweet peanut butter crumble, cooked vanilla custard and whipped cream. About 40 minutes of work, then a few hours to cool and set.
Prep Time 25 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Cool and chill 4 hours 45 minutes
Total Time 5 hours 25 minutes
Servings: 8 slices
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Calories: 560

Ingredients
  

Crust
  • 1 9-inch pie crust fully baked and cooled; graham cracker crust works too
Peanut Butter Crumble
  • 1/2 cup creamy peanut butter regular, not natural
  • 1 cup powdered sugar plus 1 tbsp more if pasty
Vanilla Custard
  • 3 cups whole milk divided: 2 1/2 cups + 1/2 cup
  • 2/3 cup granulated sugar
  • 1/3 cup cornstarch
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 3 large egg yolks
  • 2 tablespoons unsalted butter
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
Whipped Cream
  • 1 cup heavy whipping cream cold
  • 2 tablespoons powdered sugar
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

Equipment

  • 9-inch pie dish
  • - Medium saucepan
  • Whisk
  • Mixing bowls
  • - Electric mixer
  • - Rubber spatula

Method
 

Crust and Crumble
  1. Bake the pie crust fully according to your recipe or the package directions for a baked shell, then cool it completely.
  2. Cut the peanut butter and powdered sugar together with a fork or pastry blender until the mixture forms pea-size crumbs. Add powdered sugar 1 tablespoon at a time if it stays pasty.
Vanilla Custard
  1. Heat 2 1/2 cups of the milk with the sugar and salt in a medium saucepan over medium heat, stirring now and then, until the sugar dissolves and the milk steams.
  2. Whisk the remaining 1/2 cup cold milk with the cornstarch until smooth, then whisk in the egg yolks. Slowly whisk in about 1 cup of the hot milk, then pour everything back into the saucepan.
  3. Cook over medium heat, whisking constantly and scraping the corners, until thick. Once large bubbles break the surface, keep whisking for 1 more minute. Remove from the heat and stir in the butter and vanilla.
  4. Transfer the custard to a bowl, press plastic wrap onto the surface and cool on the counter for about 45 minutes, until barely warm.
Assemble
  1. Scatter about two-thirds of the crumble over the bottom of the crust. Spread the custard over it, cover and refrigerate for at least 4 hours.
  2. Whip the cream with the powdered sugar and vanilla to medium-stiff peaks. Spread it over the chilled custard and sprinkle with the remaining crumble. Slice with a knife dipped in hot water.

Notes

Storage: keep covered in the refrigerator and eat within 2 to 3 days. Freezing is not recommended: the custard weeps and turns spongy when thawed.
Make ahead: assemble the crust, crumble and custard the day before; add the whipped cream and top crumble a few hours before serving.
Substitutions: a graham cracker crust replaces the pastry; prepared instant vanilla pudding can replace the cooked custard (softer texture); natural peanut butter is not recommended because the crumble turns greasy.
The custard reaches well above 160°F, the safe minimum for egg dishes, once it has bubbled for a full minute.
Nutrition is an estimate, not a laboratory analysis.